Counter Editorials and Opinions on Current Events and Attitudes


    Volume II, Issue III                                                                                            May 2001


 

 Can The United States Make China Behave? (By R.A. Pearson)

The recent incident between the American and Chinese aircraft off the Chinese coast has highlighted the tensions that still exist between these two world powers. While many Americans still want to see the open growth of trade and investments between the two nations, Americans are asking if China is willing to act in accordance with a free and open World Trade Organization. The hard line response of both countries at the start of this unfortunate incident only served to magnify the hard feeling between the two nations.

Students of Chinese History agree that China has been dealt a tough hand by the western powers since the 1850s. Western powers crashed in China's doors in 1840 and 1857 during the British Opium Wars. By 1890 Germany, France, Russia, and even Japan created exclusive trade zones in China known as "Spheres of Influence". In these zones western laws governed the conduct of trade, business, and the behavior of foreign nationals. The western repression of the "Boxer Rebellion", an expression of Chinese nationalism and in 1900, caused China to cede even more territory and national integrity to the western powers.

The failure of the Chinese Republic, created by Sun Yat-Sen in 1911 and continued by Chiang Kai-shek, caused the rise of a Communist Party, led by Mao Tse-tung, during the 1930s. The Chinese Civil War was put on hold during World War II while Mao and Chiang fought the Japanese. Chiang, however, stockpiled American lend-lease weapons to use against the Communist after the Japanese defeat. Mao never forgot that American weapons were used against him, and the Chinese peasants never forgot that Chiang's government was corrupt. Mao defeated Chiang in 1949, and Chiang fled to Taiwan. The United States still backed Chiang and his Republic of China. Chiang kept the Chinese seat in the United Nations.
The United States refused to recognize Mao and the Peoples Republic of China and blocked the representation of one-third of the world's people in the UN.

During the Korean War (1950-1953) the United States fought the Chinese (Mao's son was killed in Korea). The United States negotiated with the Chinese to end the Korean War and again at Geneva in 1954 over the partition of Vietnam. The United States continued to diplomatically ignore China until President Nixon reopened relations in the 1970s. The Peoples Republic of China finally received American recognition and the Chinese people's seat at the UN and on the UN Security Council. The United States continued to recognize Taiwan as a separate state and here lies one of the major problems.

The Peoples Republic of China has never renounced its claim to Taiwan. The EP-3E spy plane flights over this area are designed to gather intelligence over the sensitive area of the Straits of Formosa. The recent incident occurred at a time when the United States will consider selling Taiwan several new and advanced destroyers equipped with the latest Aegis radar and other technological advances. On April 23, the Bush Administration released information that the sale of the Aegis destroyers would not take place in the near future; however, it left open the possibility of the sell at a later date. When the Bush Administration elected to sell Taiwan older weapons, China protested even these sells. There is also a United States fear that Taiwan might declare its independence from China. This action would provoke a war in the area. The United States must walk a tight rope on these issues.

The Chinese are hoping to host the 2008 Olympic Games at Beijing. In order to do this the Chinese must persuade the world that it is willing to abide by the established rules of diplomacy and international behavior. The Chinese recognize that they must overcome the world reaction to their recent crack down on the religious group known as Falun Gong. Many Americans felt that pressure could be put on the Olympic Selection Committee to refuse the Chinese the Olympic Games; however, America is low on the Olympic Committees " to appease" list. The Atlanta Olympics were considered "tacky" by many around the world, and the recent airing of the Olympic Selection Committee's dirty laundry over the Salt Lake City selection has damaged the United States credibility with the Olympic organizers. The Committee could select Beijing just to spite the United States.

China probably hurt itself on an important trade issue being considered later in the year by the United States Congress. If Congress follows the harsh rhetoric handed out by several Congressmen, China could face trade sanctions and be denied entrance into the World Trade Organization. This action would raise trade barriers such as tariffs and stifle investments in Chinese industries. China would find it harder to move from a command economy (one based on government needs) to a market economy (one based on consumer demand).

The Chinese response to the spy plane incident was to intern the American crew and demand a US apology. The "accident" occurred in international airspace and the American crew landed in accordance with established and recognized international procedure. The pilot and crew are to be applauded for landing of the plane. When Chinese leader Jiang Zemin (party chief, president, and leader of the Central Military Commission) left China for a previously scheduled trip to Latin America, the hard line military leadership began to influence negotiations. This hard line stance and President Bush's initial hard line rhetoric created a stand off for several days.

America and the world agree the spy plane incident was caused by a hot shot Chinese pilot "buzzing" an American EP-3E spy plane. The initial Bush Administration's hard-line comments created a standoff
for several days as the 24 American crewmen and women were detained on Hainan island where the plane had landed. Only after the cooler voices of Secretary of State Colin Powell and National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice began to tone down the hard line rhetoric did the negotiations began to move in a more positive direction.

The US Ambassador to China, Retired Admiral Joseph Prueher (a Clinton appointee) aided American efforts by working out acceptable language to be used in the American note regarding the incident. The note allowed the Unites States to say we were sorry without really saying we were sorry. Once the language was agreed to by both nations, the crew was allowed to return to the United States. Diplomacy had overcome saber rattling, an important lesson for President Bush.

The Bush Administration needs to work more on its "Asian Team" which is well stocked with experts on Japan but lacking on experts on China, Korea, India, and Pakistan. The Chinese are still seething over the 1999 American bombing of its Belgrade Embassy. The problems on the Indian-Pakistani border could cause a war at any time. North Korea can not feed its population. These hot spots and hurt feelings need more attention than business relations with Japan do.

The United States cannot browbeat China into accepting our style of democracy, our economic philosophy or our concept of human rights. We can allow China to move toward these at its own pace. Perhaps the answer to questions posed by the latest spy plane incident is to let it pass into history. China once again is facing a secession problem as older leaders like Jaing Zemin give up their positions in the government, party, and military. China observers believe that the Communist Party has lost all vestiges of legitimacy, and now it must appeal to nationalism to unite its people. China wants the Olympics. There is a rising middle class in China. The Internet, cell phones, and satellite television make Chinese isolation impossible. World trade will move China toward a market economy, human rights, and democracy. Change will come to China. Perhaps a million pairs of blue jeans will deliver what a thousand bombs could not - help China forgive and find a way to behave.


 Bob Kerrey: Under Fire Once Again (By Sam Merier)           Back to Top

The recent 60 MINUTES (CBS) report concerning Senator Bob Kerrey (D.-Neb.) has opened a yet another controversy concerning America's conduct of the Vietnam War. The 60 MINUTES report centered around Bob Kerrey, then a 25 year old Navy SEAL officer, who later became a US Senator from Nebraska. During the war Kerrey won the Bronze Star, the Congressional Medal of Honor, and the Purple Heart loosing part of a leg in the action where he won the Medal of Honor. It was the engagement in which he won the Bronze Star that the 60 MINUTES report covered.

The action occurred on 25 February 1969 at the village of Thang Phong, South Vietnam, a known Viet Cong Hamlet in the delta of the Mekong River. The SEALs' mission that night was to abduct or kill a VC chieftain in the area. The area was designated a free fire zone. Kerrey led his SEAL squad in the raid and was awarded the Bronze Star afterwards.

According to Kerrey and the entire squad, the enemy opened fire on them outside the village. The SEALs returned fire and pressed on through the village killing about 21 people assumed to be Viet Cong. One team member, Gerhard Klann, alleged and 60 MINUTES reported that the team intentionally killed at least 12 civilians including women and children. Senator Kerrey now admits that mistakes were made and women and children were killed, but that these deaths were not intentional. Another SEAL team member, Mike Ambrose, verifies Kerrey's recollection of the incident.

The great-unasked question continues to be "Why blame Kerrey?" When asked by a young reporter if Kerrey would give back the Bronze Star awarded for the Thang Phong action he replied he would not. Several reporters and commentators have even indicated that he should return the Medal of Honor won in another action where he lost part of his leg. It may even be possible that the press may ask him if he thinks he should return his Purple Heart!

Unfortunately, the media did not consider Kerrey's orders, to abduct (kill) the VC chieftain in a free fire zone, whey they criticized his conduct of the raid. In his after action report Kerrey was required to give a body count, a very important part of the military procedure at the time and reported once a week on the network news. Kerrey was responsible for carrying out his orders and the lives of the men on the SEAL team. It was a dark night. The way in was possibly mined, rigged with booby traps, and full of snakes, insects, and VC. The enemy was courageous, dedicated, and deceitful. The enemy never failed to use women and children as human shields or as soldiers. There were few non-combatants in a free fire zone.

Perhaps the real villains in the Bob Kerrey story are policy makers who sent American youths to a war that we could not win. Business leaders and politicians had investments they would loose if South Vietnam fell. The political leaders refused to bomb or attack important civilian or military targets in North Vietnam. The political-military-industrial complex lined their pockets with profits while young men like Bob Kerrey fought an impossible war. Blame LBJ, Nixon, and the members of Congress who voted the funds for the war. We can point our fingers at the entire system that gave ambiguous orders to a 25 year old who led 19 and 20 year olds into combat. But let's not blame Bob Kerrey for following orders.

Perhaps Senator Kerrey cannot return his medals even if required to do so. Perhaps (and this is pure speculation) he left them at the "Wall". Kerrey has spent 30+ years trying to deal with a 3-month tour in "Nam". He has worked hard to make America and the world a better place. The American people and media forgave President Clinton, a coward who dodged the draft, who admittedly loathed the military, and as President sold American secrets to the Chinese. Surely the American people will allow an honorable man like Senator Kerrey who fought for, bled for, and gave part of his limb for our country, to continue to serve in any and all elected positions he may obtain.


 Speakin' Southern: Stump Slung Chit'lens (Chitterlings)          Back to Top

Stump Slung Chit'lens- Chitterlings (hog intestines) cleaned by standing on a 3 foot high stump and being slung around the head until all the inside matter has been slung out. The chitterlings are then thoroughly washed and squeezed out by hand. They are then boiled or fried and served with pure cane syrup.

Usage-
Woody- "Hay ma. These here chit'lens stump slung?"
Ma- "I don't know, Woody. Why?"
Woody- " I don't reckon so. I just got a san' spur stuck in my gum."

VISIT SWINE TIME COUNRTY FESTIVAL IN CLIMAX, GA., ON THE SATURDAY AFTER THANKSGIVING. EVENTS INCLUDE A 5-K RUN, COUNTRY GAMES, CRAFTS, PARADE, FOOD, AND… PLENTY OF CHIT'LENS.


 Gun Enthuestics Aim For A Patron Saint          Back to Top

John Snyder, a former editor of the National Rifle Association's magazine, The American Rifleman, is leading the push to have St. Gabriel Possenti proclaimed as the Patron Saint of gun owners and self-defense. St. Gabriel Possenti, already canonized in 1920 by Pope Benedict XV, is reported to have defended an Italian village against a marauding band of mercenaries in 1860.

Church authorities indicate that while St. Gabriel Possenti lived a life "renowned for sanctity and miracles", no evidence exists to substantiate his defense of the village. However the book One Year Book of Saints, by Reverend Clifford Stevens, relates this account of the incident:

"On a summer day a little over a hundred years ago, a slim figure in a black cassock
stood facing a gang of mercenaries in a small town in Piedmont, Italy. He had just disarmed
one of the soldiers who was attacking a young girl, had faced the rest of the band fearlessly,
then drove them out of the village at the point of a gun."

According to the story when the leader of the band scoffed at the Priest's ability with a gun, Possenti pointed the firearm at a lizard running across the road and shot the unlucky reptile clean through the head.

St. Gabriel Possenti died of tuberculosis at the age of 24 before his abilities with a firearm could be proven and verified.

There are many Patron Saints in the Church today. St. Thomas Moore is the Patron Saint of politicians. St. George is the Patron Saint of soldiers, and St. Jude is the Patron Saint of lost causes. Gun owners feel they need a Patron Saint also.

The St. Gabriel Possenti Society is located in Arlington, Virginia, and is headed by John Snyder. The feast day of St. Gabriel Possenti is February 27th.


 Free E-Mail: News From www.Southerndomains.Com          Back to Top

The web site http://www.southerndomains.com announces free e-mail service to people who wish to express their southern identity by using a southern e-mail address. The selections include over 60 names with a southern flavor including: SouthernFemme, LadiesSouth, SportsSouth, SouthenTruckers, SouthernWriter, SouthernGrits, and SouthernRednecks. The unique setup of this e-mail system allows the user to access their e-mail from any Internet location on the globe. The e-mail system allows for total privacy for the user of the service.

To sign up for free southern e-mail, log on to the http://www.southerndomains.com home page and go to the e-mail service page. There you will find easy to follow instructions on how to become a southern e-mail user. Simply select the name you wish to receive your free southern e-mail under and sign on.
Southerndomains also offers southerndomain names for sell for people interested in establishing southern oriented web sites.

The CLARION ISSUE is the official newspaper of southerndomains.com. While there you can view the CLARION ISSUE archives including all the "dog gone" wisdom dispersed by our most popular columnist 'Cluny'.

Check it out. We'll see ya'll on the World Wide Web.


 A Little Souther Humor: Duck Hunting-Alabama Style          Back to Top

A big-city lawyer, from Washington, D.C., went duck hunting in the Alabama low country. He shot and dropped a bird, but it fell into a farmer's field on the other side of a fence. As the lawyer climbed over the fence, an elderly farmer drove up on his tractor and asked him what he was doing. The lawyer responded, "I shot a duck and it fell in this field, and now I'm going in to retrieve it."

The old farmer replied, "This is my property, and you are not coming over here." The indignant lawyer said, "I am one of the best trial attorneys in the U.S. If you don't let me get that duck, I'll sue you and take everything you own."

The old farmer smiled and said, "Apparently, you don't know how we do things in Alabama. Down here we settle small disagreements like this with the three-kick-rule."

The lawyer asked, "The three-kick-rule-what is the three-kick-rule?"

The farmer replied, "Well, first I kick you three times, and then you kick me three times, and so on, back and forth, until someone gives up."

The attorney quickly thought about the proposed contest and decided that he could easily take the old codger. He agreed to abide by the local custom.

The old farmer slowly climbed down from the tractor and walked up to the city feller. His first kick planted the toe of his heavy work boot into the lawyer's groin and dropped him to his knees. His second kick nearly wiped the man's nose off his face. The attorney was flat on his belly when the farmer's third kick to the kidney area nearly caused him to give up.

The lawyer summoned every bit of his will, managed to get to is feet, and said, "Okay, you old coot, now it's my turn."

The old farmer smiled and said, "Naw, I give up. You can have the duck."


Back to Top

Quote of Month
Ecology (coming soon)